Workforce Operations
How to Choose Timekeeping Software for a Small Government Contractor
Bring one example to every demo and compare what happens to daily hours, corrections, approvals and the records handed to accounting.
Choose timekeeping software by watching it handle the work your employees, supervisors and accounting team need to complete. Bring the same example to each demonstration and keep a record of what the vendor shows.
For a small government contractor, useful tests follow hours from daily entry through correction, approval and the handoff to payroll or accounting. They also show what happens when a step is incomplete.
DCAA’s contractor FAQ states that the agency does not recommend or approve specific vendor accounting software. Your evaluation needs to consider the product together with the policies, people and controls that will operate it.
Start with the work your current process cannot handle well
Write down the problems that prompted the search. Perhaps employees see outdated charge codes, corrections arrive by email or accounting cannot tell which export belongs to the approved period.
Make each problem specific enough to demonstrate. “Better reporting” is difficult to evaluate. “Show the hours, approvals and export used for this employee’s period” gives the vendor a concrete task.
Agree on the scope before comparing products. Identify the payroll and accounting systems that will remain, the people who review time and the records they need. DCAA’s overview of cost-type requirements describes an accounting system as more than a software package: its methods, procedures and controls matter too.
Your finance or compliance lead should identify the requirements that apply to your contracts. Use those requirements to decide which demonstration tests are essential.
Bring one fictional employee and a small set of codes
Use demonstration data rather than real employee or contract information.
For this example, Dana Lee records a five-day workweek with seven hours on Project A and one hour on Administration each day. The weekly total is forty hours.
After certification and supervisor approval, Dana discovers that two of Friday’s Project A hours belonged to Project B. Both project codes were authorized for Dana on that date.
| Record | Project A hours | Project B hours | Administration hours | Total worked hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original approved week | 35.00 | 0.00 | 5.00 | 40.00 |
| Corrected week | 33.00 | 2.00 | 5.00 | 40.00 |
The weekly total remains the same. The allocation changes.
Ask the vendor to show the original record, the correction reason, the people involved and the review required by the configured policy. Then follow the corrected record into the next handoff.
These are fictional worked hours for a software demonstration. The table does not calculate wages, overtime, billable labor or a required weekly target.
Use seven tests in every demonstration
Take this scorecard to each vendor. Record the product edition, configuration and date, along with what you observed.
| Test | Ask the vendor to show | Evidence to record |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Authorized charge codes | Dana’s available codes on a specific date, then what happens with an unauthorized or expired code. | Which restrictions operate, who maintains them and how effective dates are handled. |
| 2. Daily entry and late changes | A normal entry, a later entry and a delegated entry if that workflow is needed. | How the system distinguishes work dates, entry times, changes and the person who acted. |
| 3. Certification and approval | Employee certification, supervisor review and an attempted self-approval. | Who may take each action and what record identifies the version reviewed. |
| 4. Correction after approval | Dana’s two-hour move from Project A to Project B. | Original and revised values, reason, actor, timestamps and the subsequent review path. |
| 5. Period readiness | A period with one missing certification, one waiting approval and one unresolved leave item. | How staff find incomplete work, who resolves it and how exceptions are handled. |
| 6. Payroll/accounting handoff | An export or supported integration using the reviewed records, followed by an updated handoff after the correction. | Field mapping, totals, version or batch identity, delivery status and duplicate handling. |
| 7. Retrieval and continued access | The records for one employee and period, including supporting history and permitted exports. | What can be retrieved, who can access it, retention settings and the process if the company leaves the service. |
A manual step can be workable when its owner, evidence and limitations are clear. Write it down so the comparison reflects the process your team would actually run.
If a required feature is on the roadmap, record it as unavailable today. A planned capability should not receive the same treatment as a workflow demonstrated in the proposed configuration.
Score the evidence and keep essential gaps visible
Use a simple purchasing scale:
- 0: The required workflow was not demonstrated or is unavailable.
- 1: Part of the workflow was shown, or it depends on a manual step, additional product or unconfirmed configuration.
- 2: The required workflow was demonstrated in the proposed setup, with an understandable record.
The score compares demonstrations. It does not measure DCAA compliance.
Mark essential requirements separately. A high total should not hide a missing capability your team needs to operate. Record a follow-up owner and due date for each unresolved question.
| Vendor / edition | Demo date | Essential requirement | What was demonstrated | Score | Open question / owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Opens your browser’s print dialog with only the worked example, the seven tests and the blank scorecard.
Inspect the handoff beyond the timesheet screen
An attractive timesheet is only part of the evaluation. Ask payroll or accounting to review a sample output before choosing a product.
Check employee identifiers and code mappings against the receiving process. Compare the approved source with the proposed handoff. Confirm how the team recognizes a replacement export after a correction.
DCAA’s accounting-system presentation discusses reconciling labor distribution with payroll and tracing records to the ledgers. The software demonstration should make it clear which parts the product handles and which remain with your team or another system.
Our timesheet-to-payroll reconciliation checklist walks through that operational review in more detail.
Include the people who will use it
Let an employee enter time, a supervisor review it and an accounting user inspect the output. Ask each person to complete the task they will own.
Confirm the work needed before the first live period: employee setup, code assignments, role configuration, training and the treatment of historical records. Agree on who owns each item.
Compare the full proposal. Separate subscription fees from implementation, optional modules and support. Ask what assistance is included when the first period exposes a mapping or workflow problem.
A product that fits the demonstration still needs a practical rollout plan.
What to test in a HelmRow demo
HelmRow’s timekeeping tools support daily entry against authorized codes, separate employee certification and supervisor approval, retained correction history and visibility into incomplete periods.
Its public product description also covers traceable export batches. It does not promise a named payroll integration. Bring a sample of the fields your receiving system needs so the handoff can be examined. The payroll export page describes that handoff: a file for the payroll provider you already use, then a comparison of the provider’s results with what was sent.
Use the same scorecard for HelmRow that you use elsewhere. Ask to follow Dana’s original entry through the correction and export, then inspect the record as each relevant role. HelmRow’s how-to videos show the everyday tasks on the application itself, so you can see several of the seven tests before the demo starts.
For more detail before the demo, see charge codes, correction history and the supervisor approval checklist.
Common purchasing questions
Can software make our company compliant automatically?
A product can support controls and retain evidence. Your organization must configure it appropriately and operate its policies, reviews and accounting processes. Evaluate those responsibilities alongside the software.
Do we need to replace payroll and accounting too?
That depends on the scope of the problem and the proposed system. Identify what will remain, then test how timekeeping records will reach those systems before deciding.
What should we bring to a demo?
Bring fictional employee and code examples, the relevant approval steps, a list of essential requirements and a sanitized example of the output your receiving system needs.
Request a HelmRow demo and ask to work through the scorecard with your HR, payroll or accounting lead.